Email to Cllr. John Sheahan re. “Open Season” on Hen Harriers statement

Open season on Hen Harrier in the Limerick leaderI’m at a loss to understand what Cllr. John Sheahan could have been thinking when he made his “Open Season” on hen harriers statement (as reported in the Limerick Leader and outlined on this site here).

I felt compelled (along with many other people I’m sure) to write to Cllr. Sheahan expressing my thoughts on his frankly outrageous statement. You’ll find the full text of my email below.

I will of course publish any response I receive from Cllr. Sheahan as an addendum to this post.

From: Calvin Jones

To: Cllr. John Sheahan

CC: Minister Simon Coveney, Minister Jimmy Deenihan, Minister Phil Hogan, Limerick County Manager

Subject: Hen Harrier Remarks

Dear Cllr. Sheahan,

It was with some disbelief that I read about your recent comments in relation to the hen harrier. At first I thought it was a very poor joke. I found it hard to believe a serving public representative would go on record with a statement so blatantly outrageous.

It seems however I may have overestimated the calibre of public representatives in some parts of the country. Your apparent advocacy of an “open season” on hen harriers is bewildering.

I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that your intention was not to encourage people to go out and shoot hen harriers (that would be both morally reprehensible and quite probably illegal). But you occupy a position of some authority, and with that comes a modicum of responsibility. What you say carries weight and influence… and it doesn’t take a huge leap of imagination to see that some frustrated people will latch on to your statement as vindication to heap yet more misery on an already beleaguered species.

Hen harriers remain in dire straits, here in Ireland and in the UK, thanks to decades of persecution and inappropriate land use. People put the hen harrier in its current predicament, and if anything existing conservation measures do not go far enough to redress the balance. Your demands that those same conservation measures be slackened shows an astonishingly sparse understanding of the underlying issues.

As you are fully aware, hen harriers are a species of high conservation concern here in Ireland and are protected under national and international legislation. Any suggestion that people should intentionally harm the birds is tantamount to an incitement to commit crime. That’s inexcusable from anyone, but is utterly reprehensible from an elected politician.

I live in a rural Irish community and fully understand the needs of farmers and other landowners to generate revenue from their land. I support initiatives that allow them to do so — but with appropriate consideration for wildlife that not only shares that land, but occupied it long before the farmers, or even the farms, arrived. Hen harrier SPAs don’t categorically prevent landowners from exploring a range of development options — but they do ensure that development only happens within certain constraints with due consideration for the incumbent wildlife. That’s as it should be.

We all rely on our environment for our health and well-being… even, at the risk of sounding overly dramatic, for our survival. We have a duty of care to maintain it for future generations, and to restore it wherever we can to a healthier state. Maintaining the biodiversity that supports a functioning ecosystem is part and parcel of that responsibility — and yes, that includes the hen-harrier.

I sincerely hope that the Government Ministers copied on this email, and the Limerick County Manager, will look into this matter with some urgency, and will take whatever measures they feel are appropriate under the circumstances. Meanwhile I urge you to issue a public retraction of the statement and an unambiguous apology that will go at least some way to mitigate the potential damage you may have caused.

Yours sincerely

Calvin Jones

NB. A copy of this email will be published on the blog at www.irelandswildlife.com, along with any response I receive.

Calvin Jones
Founder and Managing Editor, Ireland’s Wildlife

Update 26/07/2013: I received a response from Cllr. Sheahan this morning

About Calvin Jones

Calvin Jones is a freelance writer, author, birder and lifelong wildlife enthusiast. He is founder and managing editor of IrelandsWildlife.com. He is also the tour leader and wildlife guide on our West Cork based Discover Wildlife tours.
Calvin is also co-author of bestselling digital marketing titles and offers digital business consulting services and training through Digital Marketing Success

Comments

  1. Owen Mc Carthy says:

    I support your principals fully Calvin, keep up the good work. We need more people like you, as i believe there is still a very poor attitude towards animal welfare in this country…broadly speaking.

    • Thanks Owen.

      I agree, but I also think there’s a growing affinity for the natural world around us, and that people are becoming more aware of the issues… if a little slowly. One of the reasons I set up the Ireland’s Wildlife site was to help make wildlife and nature more accessible and engaging to more people. It’s still early days… but I hope it’s moving in the right direction.

  2. michael ryan says:

    While John Sheehans comments may have been inappropriate, they are indicitative of what happens when people are faced with bad laws. In other words when legal and political remedies do not work people are compelled to use other routes.

    My view is very simply and I believe reasonable. If society wishes to protect the hen harrier (as I believe it should) then society should compensate people who lose out fianancialy.

    It is absolutely frustrating for many land owners that their land usage options are severly curtailed without any right to compensation. This is particulary so when all the evidence would suggest that afforestation, the most common alternative land use in SPAs if properly managed is actually beneficial to this bird. yet the planting of forests is completely banned in these areas.

    No wonder people and their representatives are frustrated and call for drastic action.”

Trackbacks

  1. […] night I penned this email to Cllr. John Sheahan, Cathaoirleach of Limerick County Council, in response to his outrageous […]

  2. […] you can see my email to Cllr. Sheahan here, and his response […]

Leave a Reply

Like most other websites Ireland's Wildlife uses cookies to enhance your user experience - by using the site or closing this banner you agree to our use of cookies as outlined in our Privacy policy here.
No problem!
x